Still prefer the Tortue QP

Sep 06, 2011,14:03 PM
 


Just purely from design point of view.

Another comprehensive report and excellent close up photos.

Best,

Horo

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

A perpetual in another case - the Calibre de Cartier QP

 
 By: SJX : August 21st, 2011-08:19
The perpetual calendar in the Fine Watchmaking line was originally launched in the Tortue case. Though it has a well proportioned face, the perpetual calendar in that case is too thick and presents an inelegant profile in my opinion. The Tortue Quantieme ...  

Thanks a lot SJX for the post.

 
 By: foversta : August 21st, 2011-14:50
I prefer the Calibre case for this complication but I don't like the font which is used... it seems to be too "computerized". Fx

Computerised

 
 By: SJX : August 22nd, 2011-20:28
That is the right description Foversta. It reminds me of the so-called "computer" dial of Rolex. - SJX

Agree

 
 By: halkcb : August 31st, 2011-20:36
with your comment on the computerised nature of the font----that's why the tortue version with guilloche is more appealing to me a side comment is why don't they start the day mode with sunday rather than monday? any reason? best

tortue for me

 
 By: playtime : August 21st, 2011-19:12
just a matter of taste....... J

I'm impressed

 
 By: Davo : August 22nd, 2011-14:23
Looks fantastic in the Calibre case. Definitely must check that one out. Thanks for posting, SJX.

I agee the skeleton version would be very nice

 
 By: cazalea : August 23rd, 2011-11:03
plus they could save all that fancy dial engraving and give us air instead. A great solution except for the obvious problem of how to support the Cartier name placque Cheers Cazalea

Definitely like the Calibre better than the Tortue

 
 By: docsnov : August 26th, 2011-13:53
I am usually not a fan of skeletonized cases, so I am not sure I would like a skeletonized Calibre better than the models shown. Thanks for the pictures and report. Stewart

Thanks JX

 
 By: DaMctosh : September 6th, 2011-08:52
It's the Tortue for me. It has that classic Cartier look and balance. Even though the round movement is more suited to the Calibre, I find the case unnecessarily big and inelegant in some ways. It looked good to me until I put it on my wrist and somehow i... 

Still prefer the Tortue QP

 
 By: Hororgasm : September 6th, 2011-14:03
Just purely from design point of view. Another comprehensive report and excellent close up photos. Best, Horo