A Very Unique Historical (Cartier) Watch

May 21, 2015,09:59 AM
 

A few weeks ago I attended a gala opening of the ballet La Sylphide by the New York City Ballet at Lincoln Center, as a guest of Vacheron Constantin., who is a major sponsor. In all, a wonderful evening.
Since I was in New York for this gala, I also arranged to pick up a watch I had recently won at auction.

Last week was also significant from another point of view. The week marked the liberation of Holland by Canadian troops on May 5th 1945 and the surrender of Germany to the Allies on May 7th. (Another signing was on May 9th in Berlin at the insistence of the Soviets). Celebratory events took place throughout week in Holland France and culminating today in London and Moscow.

In the early hours of May 7th, at 2:41 am, in the small French town of Reims (Rheims), the centre of the champagne district and the site of the beautiful Reims cathedral; and at that time the headquarters of General Eisenhower (SHAEF – Supreme Headquarters of the Allied Expeditionary Forces), the initial documents of complete surrender of Germany were signed.

The building, colloquially known as “the little red schoolhouse”, was a boys’ school,: Le College Moderne et Technique de Reims and was Eisenhower’s command centre.

 



The Little Red Schoolhouse







And it was there in the recreation hall that the brief ceremony took place. The document was signed by General Walter Bedell “Beetle” Smith for the Allies, General Ivan Susloparov for the Soviets and witnessed by General François Sevez of the Free French. The unconditional surrender was signed by General Alfred Jodl for the Germans.


 





General Walter Bedell Smith, Eisenhower's Chief of Staff




May 7th, 1945 Surrender Document





German General Alfred Jodl signing





General Smith signing for the Allies

General Smith was Eisenhower’s Chief of Staff and was known to be a tough no-nonsense and very capable individual whom Eisenhower relied upon as his “go-to guy”. To some he was considered a “hatchet-man” because of his abrupt and peremptory style. But he was a skillful diplomat and got on well with the British including the insufferable Montgomery, smoothing over difficulties between the Allies. He was also able to handle Ike’s sometimes querulous generals such as Bradley and Patton.

Among “Beetle” Smith’s many accomplishments were initiating the surrender of Italy and its transfer to the Allied cause, negotiating the transfer of food and supplies to the starving Dutch civilian population and negotiating the complete surrender of German forces in Holland to the Canadian Army. He also successfully arranged the surrender of all German forces, whose leaders were simply stalling for time, in part by threatening to seal the front and leave the German forces in the East to the “mercies of the Red Army.

After the war he was appointed Ambassador to the USSR and in 1950 became head of the newly formed CIA.  He later served as  Assistant Secretary of State under Dulles.
Since the trip had been arranged many weeks before and the auction held in April, I made a note of it all and put it out of my mind.

After arriving in New York I headed over to the auction house to pick up my prize. I inspected it and left for Madison Avenue and the Vacheron Boutique. But as I walked out I looked at the inscription on the back: “May 7th, 1945”.

Then the unexpected irony of the situation hit me. The day I received the watch was May 7th !

Now, you may be asking yourself at this time: “Why all the WWII history and attention to Walter Bedell Smith”?

Well the answer follows below.



 


A typical Cartier box from the 1940’s


 



The Cartier logo on a satin cushion


 


The front of the 1904 $20 coin watch.





Cartier polished the original markings from the back of the $20 gold piece and have inscribed:


Reims

May 7th, 1945

0241 (ETO)


The place: Reims, France

The date: May, 7th 1945

The time: 2:41 A.M.  European Theatre of Operations






On the inside is engraved: “LOUIS from BEDELL














The watch face has the typical Cartier hand and Roman numerals, still used today.

And very surprising, the watch works and keeps fairly accurate time.

You also might be wondering who “Louis” is. Well this took some time and detective work. At first I thought it might be Louis Mountbatten. But I do not believe Smith ever met him. I checked the names of many general officers but to no avail… no Louis!

Then I discovered that both Smith and Eisenhower had a good friend by the name of Louis who they knew from their days at West Point. He was Louis Marx who became a toy magnate and who with his brother founded Marx Toys, which produced a great many of the toys in America for decades. At one point he was the largest toy manufacturer in the world. He was called “The Toy King” and “The Henry Ford of Toys”.


 





For me this was a great find. It is a unique historical piece and a link with the past and marks the beginning of the end of a momentous world-wide struggle.


 











This message has been edited by MTF on 2015-05-22 07:25:19

  login to reply

Comments: view entire thread

 

Amazing post!

 
 By: foversta : May 21st, 2015-13:42
Your post really speaks to me. My grand-father was a US soldier and several family members fought in Europe after the D-Day. Great pics, great text, thanks a lot for this amazing post which also gives another example of the use of the 20 USD coin! Thanks ... 

Thank you for sharing this piece of history!

 
 By: blomman Mr Blue : May 21st, 2015-13:57
Wonderful catch! Congratulation! :) Best Blomman

Fantastic Post! Bravo

 
 By: cazalea : May 21st, 2015-16:56
I love this kind of thing. Thank you for taking the time to put together this story for us. Cazalea

What great provenance

 
 By: ik2000 : May 21st, 2015-21:11
And your pictures and background to it all are superb. Thanks for sharing.... Timepieces, I feel, can be like trees... Inanimate objects that have been able to witness some of history's great events, but keep all the secrets to themselves!

History & watchmaking

 
 By: tudorctin : May 22nd, 2015-02:00
Thanks for this interesting history lesson! Constantin

Excellent post!

 
 By: Ares501 - Mr Green : May 22nd, 2015-02:46
Congrats on winning such important piece not only for Cartier Sincerely D

What a write-up, a pleasure to read !..

 
 By: hs111 : May 22nd, 2015-08:50
Providing informatiom about aspects of horology & the historical context in those very important days of May 1945. You have to be commended and thanked for sharing these events & pictures of a very decisive time for Europe, no - almost the whole world. It... 

When a watch "speaks" its awesome..

 
 By: Roni M : May 22nd, 2015-09:49
Congrats to owning such a wonderful timepiece! Roni

Many thanks to all for your kind and generous comments!

 
 By: yesjb : May 23rd, 2015-13:05
I am very pleased you enjoyed the post. I felt that I needed to share with other Cartier aficionados this significant historical watch. It has a very interesting history as you can see. I know that Cartier has extensive archives and I will bring the watch... 

Please Joseph contact me before your visit.

 
 By: foversta : May 25th, 2015-10:53
We will try to organize something special to celebrate the watch... and your presence! Fx

You are too kind, F-X

 
 By: yesjb : May 27th, 2015-07:13
I will certainly do that. Unfortunately I missed you at SIHH, so it will be a real pleasure seeing you again. Warm regards, Joseph

Louis

 
 By: georgetownhoya : June 10th, 2015-09:43
yesjb, I wanted to congratulate you on your acquisition of the incredible Cartier coin watch. I don't know if you happened to see it, but I wrote about it on HODINKEE and think it is the most incredible coin watch in the world. After some digging, I belie... 

i don't think so

 
 By: yesjb : June 10th, 2015-16:18
There are several reasons that it wasn't a gift to General Leyer which I have mentioned in private emails. The most compelling comes from my contact at Antiquorum who informed me that the source of the watch was domestic (ie American). I will check furthe...